Chillicothe Serial Killer
- Megan Lancaster, 25 – Missing Since April 3, 2013 (Often not included in the count)
- Charlotte Trego, 25 – Missing Since May 3, 2014.
- Tameka Lynch, 30 – Disappeared May 3, 2014 - Found dead in the Paint Creek, 20 miles away from where she was last seen near Chillicothe on May 24, 2014.
- Tiffany Sayre, 26 – Disappeared May 11, 2014 - Was found murdered on June 20, 2015 by hikers in the Highland Nature Sanctuary, Just a few miles from where Tameka Lynch was found.
- Shasta Himelrick, 20 – Disappeared December 26, 2014 - Pregnant at the time of her disappearance. Her body was recovered from Scioto River on January 2, 2015. The coroner ruled her death a suicide.*
- Wanda Lemons, 37 – Missing since November 3, 2014 - She was known to move around quite a bit, and many believe she simply skipped town.
- Timberly Claytor, 38 – Was murdered on May 29, 2015, cause of death was due to gunshot wounds. A man named Jason McCrary has since been convicted of her murder *
Lumberton Serial Killer
- Christina Bennet, 32, Found on April 18th 2017 inside an abandoned house
- Rhonda Jones, 36, Found on April 18th 2017 across the street from Bennet in a garbage can (Obituary)
- Megan Ann Oxendine, 28, found June 3rd 2017 three block from the other 2 bodies. We know she was alive in mid-April when she spoke with a local new affiliate about her friend Rhonda Jones.
- Cynthia Jacobs, 41, Missing since July 2017. May have been the last person to see Megan Ann Oxendine alive.
- Abby Patterson*, 20, Missing since September 5th.
- Lisa Hardin, 36, was found in January 2009 in the woods behind a warehouse. The cause of death was blunt force trauma.
- Michelle Driggers, 23, was found in March 2009 in a cemetery roughly a mile from where Hardin was found. Driggers had been sexually assaulted, strangled and stabbed.
Pittsburgh Serial Killer
- Jimmy Slack, 25 - His body was found, with wallet and phone, on January 23rd, 2012 on the shore of the Ohio River near the Carnegie Science Center.
- Jacob Lipp, 27 - on December 16, 2012 around 3am, Jacob got into a fight with his girlfriend, who left him at the McDonalds in the Strip District after partying at Static Night Club. His body was found Dec. 12, 2014 in Beaver Falls.
- Andre Grey, 34* - Gray was reported missing from his Lawrenceville home on Oct. 25, 2014. His body was discovered on March 20 near a barge at the Market Street Bridge that spans the Ohio River in Brooke County, West Virginia.
- Paul Kochu, 22 - On Dec.16, 2014 Paul was drinking with friend at Smokin Joe's on Pittsburgh’s South Side. His friends left him alone to go get food and when they returned Paul was gone. Paul was discovered on March 20 in West Virginia.
- Ronald Yancoskie, 35 - Ronald had attended a Pirates game on Wednesday May 27, 2015, and was last seen around 7pm headed towards the T station, which he was planning to take home. His body was found at the train track above Station Square, near the Wabash Tunnel.
- David J. Carter, 26 - David was last spotted on January 18th on the Homestead Gray's Bridge. His body was found on Feb 24th in the Monongahela River in Homestead. Allegheny County Medical Examiner's Office ruled the death a suicide on Feb 26th.
- Dakota "Koty" James, 23 - Koty went missing on Jan. 25 after leaving a downtown Pittsburgh bar when he was 'denied further alcohol.' He was last seen on his phone, presumably walking towards his home to the North Side. His body was found in the Ohio River at Neville Island on March 6th, 2017.